For weeks, I’ve been going through hundreds and hundreds of websites all over the internet. I haven’t updated much, because I haven’t found anything really. But I’ve felt like I’m getting closer. Certain patterns keep coming up, certain ideas keep repeating.
Tonight, I’ve been going through forum pages on the Phantom Islands message board. It’s some pretty crazy, crackpot stuff on there. I had no idea there were so many people out there who believe Atlantis is real. I’ve been scrolling, and scrolling. And I swear, I was about to give up. I’ve had enough of reading the words of these strange, often vile people.
And then there it was, mixed in between more threads about Edgar Cayce and Heinrich Himmler: “Has anyone heard of William Sartyre”?
I swear, I felt time stop. My heart, my eyes, my hands, everything went cold.
Sartyre. Another misspelling! I realize now, I should have typed a few common misspellings into Google too, not just on WorldCat—I would have found this weeks ago.
The post was by someone named pietro9182. They say they found a book at their local library in Albuquerque called “Seafaring Tales” from 1934. They say they’ve never been able to find another copy anywhere. I searched for it on Google and found nothing either. I would believe it’s fake, except this person scanned every page, and a picture can’t lie.
And right there, on page 97, Chapter 5: William Sartyre. The entry described his voyage: a shipwreck, a strange island, another fountain of youth story. And, I read with a gasp, it mentioned that the book contained a map drawn by William himself.
Except… the page with the map had been torn out. In the scans, you can see a few shreds left from where it once was. I stared at that jagged tear on the scan until my eyes hurt. I wanted to reach through the screen and pull the map back out.
I printed each image out, that way they’re preserved on paper, safe and sound. And I looked over them, again and again. And then I finally noticed: on the first scanned page, just inside the cover, the library’s old borrowing card was still tucked in. Names scribbled in pencil, dates from decades ago. Only one name was visible above the top of the pouch: Robert Marten. 1973. I recognized that name. My stomach did a slow roll as I tried to remember. And then it hit me.
I dug back through the piles of photocopies from the library, the ones I’d made of William’s mentions in those brittle journals. The census books. All the borrowing cards and checkout records I have. And there it was. The same name. Again. And again.
Every book I’ve touched in this search, right there in the same meticulous pencil, is “Robert Marten, 1973.” How was he checking out books both from my library and in Albuquerque? And why?
Tomorrow, I’m going back to the library. I’m going to ask Peter about Robert Marten. Whoever he was, he was much more obsessed with William than I am. And I’m almost positive he’s the one who tore out that page.